1994 Ch Pontet-Canet
Double decanted for an hour and shared purely between myself and PS at Foo House this evening over an excellent steak, as well as a glass with chef Robert Foo for the outstanding dinner. The 1994 Ch Pontet-Canet was a dull “dirty-looking” purple, but the nose was immediately recognisable as Pauillac, the cedar, ash, tobacco and dried leaves were quite unmistakable. Medium-bodied on the palate with a much gentler entry than a bottle tasted at See Lim’s some 3 years back (where it was dense and monolithic), revealing excellent fruit concentration marked by fairly intense supple tannins, already developing deep secondary flavours of cassis, cinnamon and old leather against a background of plums and dark berries. This is probably the best of several of this same wine that I’ve had over the years. Drinking really well now. Excellent. My last bottle.
KP had a surprise for us when we popped over to his place for mahjong: a 1986 Les Tourelles de Longueville (second wine of Ch Pichon Baron)! I’ve never had a second wine that’s aged more than 20 years and this was really something quite unique, although it was a bit of a disappointment. Dull “tarnished” purplish red with quite a significant cork taint on the nose. On the palate, the wine was soft with less intensity than expected, the fruit beginning to dry out, resulting in some degree of hollowness as well as herbaceous qualty on the mid-palate, although its Pauillac character of ash, cigar box, dried leaves and cinnamon was still discernible.
Not terribly impressive, I’m afraid, its deficiencies laid bare by the 2000 Reserve de la Comtesse (second wine of Ch Pichon Lalande, literally just across the D2 highway from Ch Pichon Baron) that followed. Some have scoffed at this second wine, saying that it fails to resemble its grand vin, and I certainly remembered having had a few bottles of the 2000 vntage a few years before, where it was dry and austere. However, tonight’s tasting suggests that this wine has somehow turned the corner, for a rich bouquet of sweet dark fruits and vanilla literally leapt out from the deep inky red, weighty with rich layers of dark fruits and blackcurrants engulfing the palate, revealing excellent concentration and supple tannins, ending in a savoury finish. Yet to develop secondary characteristics, although notes of cinnamon and a velvety texture began emerging with time. Excellent. Pity I’ve long finished all of mine.
Sick of the repetitive old jokes, ill-mannered humor, the growing danger of being fossilised amongst dinosaurs and, worst of all, having to put up with self-important fatasses who don’t play the wine theme fairly, a breakaway faction decided to burn the bridges and wine and dine amongst ourselves instead. So, after a significant interval, we met again at Jade Palace on 22 June 2010 to enjoy some good food, great company and great wines. It also turned out to be Hiok’s 46th, and a First Growth had been promised.
We started with an oddity, the 1994 Ch Gruaud Larose (courtesy of KP), showing a rusty evolving red, rather soft, quite intense and plummy, still harboring a significant degree of minerality leading to a stern finish. Fairly complex, but devoid of opulence and aromatics and, ultimately, lacking in real distinction.
A pair of 1995s took us straight to more serious business. The 1995 Ch Troplong Mondot (courtesy of Chris), dark red with a lighter rim, displayed lovely perfumed aromatics of predominantly red fruits. Soft on the palate, revealing great concentration and intensity betraying its higher extraction, veering towards a rather stern finish. It fleshed out later in the glass, but this is still a rather youthful wine, barely developing secondary characteristics. An atypical ’95 and a very modern St-Emilion, but excellent.
The 1995 Ch Clerc Milon (courtesy of PS), deep red with an evolving rim, was lighter in texture than the Troplong Mondot. Typically Pauillac in character with plenty of smoke, cigar, ash, and secondary aromatics, soft on the palate, yet grippy, displaying excellent depth and transparency, coming across as being very “correct”. The cabernet of Clerc-Milon typically takes ages to mature, but this one has clearly mellowed, fleshing out further n the glass, becoming quite lush with time. Excellent, just lacking in ultimate opulence.
The next pairing amply demonstrates the great impact of terroir on Bordeaux wines and how much the differences may turn out to be even between adjacent communes on the Left Bank within the same vintage. The 1996 Ch Grand-Puy-Lacoste (courtesy of Vic), deep garnet red with vermillion rim, has greater density and concentration than the ’95 Clerc-Milon, yet supple. Rather restrained on the nose, but the suggestion of Pauillac is unmistakable, being more open and layered on mid-palate with ripeness of fruit that eluded the 1995s. A wine of great potential, barely entering its secondary development, beautifully balanced and elegant. This bottle seemed tighter than a bottle tasted in mid-2008 (at a most memorable lunch at Les Amis with Gary Boom, director of Bordeaux Index) as well as another in the presence of the chateau owner Xavier Borie at Iggy’s in Dec 2008, while a third bottle at the last year’s SMA Dinner was also showing beautifully. Perhaps it hadn’t been aired sufficiently. No matter. I think it’s simply wasteful to open any more of this wine. Better to save it till 2026. In contrast, the 1996 Ch Calon Segur (courtesy of Li Wei) was soft and noticeably warmer in tone, with lifted aromas and great purity of fruit and expression of its northerly terroir, reflecting the minerality of the clay soils. More mature than most other Left Bank ’96s, rounded, seamless and absolutely harmonious, consistent with my first experience last year (see Aug 2009).
The final flight consisted of two classic examples of Pessac-Leognan. The 1989 Domaine de Chevalier rouge, one of only two wines to be decanted, displayed a beautifully evolved red with an open on the nose. Not exuberant, but there’s a very controlled expression of fruit and terroir, the suggestion of gravel and earth coming through with fine intensity. Quite lush, with great transparency and depth, persistent on the finish. The nose faded somewhat with time, but the wonderful balance remained without calling attention to itself. Lovely. Truly a connoiseur’s red.
Drunk alongside, the 1994 Ch Haut Brion (courtesy of the birthday boy), a darker dusty red, was more expansive than the Domaine de Chevalier with a fruity plummy core, still quite intense on the nose. Medium full, very even and broad on the palate, absolutely harmonious and seamless, deeply layered. Lacking in opulence of the great vintages, but it still impresses with a certain rightness and ripeness of fruit that belies the vintage. Compares very well with my first experience of a ’94 Haut Brion in May 2006 at the inaugural Bacchus dinner (at the now-defunct Blue Lobster at Frankel). A seriously under-rated wine, as evidenced by how well it held up against a starry line-up of 1986 Margaux, 1982 Latour, 1989 Mouton Rothschild & 1989 Angelus on board the super-yacht White Rabbit back in Aug 2008.
I found no reason to turn down an offer of a 4-course dinner on 14 June 2010 at Bistro du Vin, paired with the 2007 wines of Domaines Sylvie Esmonin and Jean-Jacques Confuron, all for only SGD80++. Both are well-known estates, crafting quality wines that remain most reasonably priced, and both are made by women, Sophie having taken over from her father Jean-Jacques since 1988. As 2007 was a relatively poor vintage, it made perfect sense to drink these wines at this stage while they still retain their youthful freshness before the fruit dries out.
We began with the 2007 Sylvie Esmonin Bourgogne Blanc. Pale straw color with a light touch of citrus and lemon, supported by surprisingly vibrant acidity and chalky minerality. Soft, rounded and persistent. Developed an attractive creamy texture with time, becoming richer with greater intensity and attack without any greeness. Lovely.
It’s red counterpart, the 2007 Sylvie Esmonin Bourgogne Rouge, also kept pace. Dull ruby red and made in a more straightforward style, medium-bodied with fairly good concentration of raspberries and brandied cherries particularly towards the finish where it’s noticeably denser, imparting a lovely fragrance and a lingering finish. Not surprising, perhaps, that it’s rather feminine.
We then moved on to a pair of wines from Jean-Jacques Confuron, the 2007 Nuits St-Georges “les Fleurieres” (a village wine, in spite of a named location) and the 2007 Chambolle-Musigny to go with the pan-roasted barramundi. Compared to the preceding bourgogne rouge, this was ruby red with more stufing in the middle, revealing good concentration of red fruits, significantly richer with greater depth, but I can’t help feeling it’s somewhat flat and clumsy on the mid-palate. Overshadowed on this occasion by the Chambolle-Musigny village which was typically darker red, quite exuberant on the nose with ripe red fruits and occasional blackberries. Rich, rounded, with substantial depth and density in the middle layer which I find are unmistakable hallmarks of Chambolle-Musigny wines. Has power and elegance, in spite of being a bigger wine. Excellent.
We returned to Sylvie Esmonin for the final course of Coq au Vin (slow-cooked chicken leg), paired with the 2007 Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques, the only wine to be decanted. Dark ruby, exuding a heavier but lovely perfumed fragrance of red and black currrants. Deeper on the entry, with a sharper attack, but it tended to fade towards the finish. Has good density but lacking in the utter opulence that a Clos St Jacques can deliver in excellent years, although it became more even and fuller on the palate with time, developing a mild sacharine coating. In this sense, it was slightly disappointing. After taking prices into consideration, the JJ Confuron Chambolle-Musigny gets my nod as Wine of the Night.
Tasting notes from Caveau wine sale
Caveau, a subsidiary of Vinum Fine Wines, holds a superb sale once every 6 months where prices of its agency wines are slashed below cost. These are entry level Bordeaux cru bourgeois and Burgundy village, but there are occasional gems from the Right Bank, as well as Egon Muller and Alion, and knowing Vinum’s high standards, satisfaction is almost always guaranteed. Here are some notes from a tasting of selected wines at its warehouse as well as some stuff that I bought…
2006 Thibault Liger-Belair Nuits Saint-Georges “La Charmotte”, over dinner at Imperial Treasure ION. A dull tint of red. Bursting with true Burgundian flavours without any woodiness. Soft, gentle and rounded, with excellent concentration of the lovely fruit, somewhat denser at this stage on the mid-palate yet distinctive enough not to be mistaken for a New World pinot. Excellent, really. Only SGD45.
2005 Chateau D’Escurac, a Medoc cru bourgeois, decanted over lunch at Moomba. Very deep purple. Quite muted on the nose in spite of persuasive coaxing. A gentle entry leads to a medium-full wine packed with excellent fruit density. Well-balanced, ripe and supple with fine structured tannins. Has an unforced natural feel about it without any hint of over-extraction nor the usual greeness associated with Medoc wines. Much more pleasurable than Ch Bernardotte. This is performing at the entry-level of grand cru classe. Very good, really. Even Augustine of Moomba was surprised. Only SGD25. I’m glad I bought more.
If the D’Escurac was good, the 2005 Chateau D’Aurilhac, a Haut-Medoc cru bourgeois, tasted over dinner at Imperial Treasure ION, was even better. It’s outstanding, in fact. Popped and poured. Very deep red, immediately exuding loads of gorgeous dark fruits with a high tone of minerality and graphite, not unlike a St-Julien in its youth. Fruit-forward, full-bodied, high on extraction but definitely not excessive, the intensity of the glorious fruit density matched by supple sexy tannins with judicious use of wood that was totally unobtrusive. The quality and sophistication puts it definitely well within grand cru classe territory. A terrific buy at only SGD27. Even at its usual price of SGD50 (thereabouts), it’s still a bargain. A strong candidate for RWJ’s Best Affordable Red of the Year.
2007 Egon Muller Scharzhofberger Kabinett riesling, from a case of half bottles bought for only SGD31 per bottle, drunk over chilli crab at a Father’s Day dinner. Very pale. Rather restrained initially, with predominant flavours of green apples, pineapples and lime sherbet, marked by intense acidity, lively but somewhat monotonous. Developed real depth after some time, revealing layers of rich nectarine and floral fragrance, finishing with a tinge of bitter citrus. Quite excellent, but still needs time in bottle.
2005 Bodegas y Vinedos Alion. Tasted at Caveau’s warehouse. Made by Vega Sicilia. Deep red with a vermillion core. Medium-full. Notes of spice, pepper, vanilla and fresh plum from the 100% tempranillo grapes. Slightly tannic, ends in a savoury finish. Perhaps not exactly a bargain at SGD70, but I believe this wine is age-worthy; itjust needs plenty of time.
2005 L’Hospitalet de Gazin. The second wine of Ch Gazin. Deep purple. This Pomerol is very similar in character to Ch D’Escurac (above). Almost feminine. Soft, rounded, easy on the palate but has very substantial ripe fruit and weight to set it apart from a run-of-the-mill Medoc. A good buy at SGD45. Also bought a magnum of the 2004 vintage, going for only SGD70.
Champagne Pierre Peters & Guy Charlemagne
It’s probably irrelevant to ask what do rich Indonesian women know about wine, particularly if they declare quite nonchalantly that they “buy lots of wine from XXX (name of merchant/retailer) and ship them all back to Jakarta” (pronounced with that tell-tale gutteral “rrr”), something I realised when I found myself at a private wine dinner on 17 May 2010 (through Kieron…how else?) at Kome, along with 15 other high net-worth individuals and private bankers, organised by Mr Boon S Heng, an engineer by training who is better known as the founder of CEC Wine, an enthusiasts’ circle in London that went on to host several eclectic tastings attended by luminaries such as Michael Broadbent, Serena Sutcliffe and Jancis Robinson, no less.
The primary feature that evening was the champagne wines of Maison Pierre Peters, a family-owned estate situated in the Cote des Blancs since 1919, and one of several agency wines carried by Wein & Vin, a wholesaler set up by Boon. We began with a
2008 Donnhoff Riesling Trocken, a pale luminous glow with lifted aromas of citrus, honey, nectar, apricot and peach, suggesting wonderful depth. The floral fragrance carried well onto the palate with a sweet and intense expression without being overbearing, ending in a somewhat short, bitter-sweet pomelo finish, although it grew to become more persistent with time. Paired astutely with deep fried spicy mackerel, bringing out the wonderful freshness in the wine. Quite unique and delightful.
The Pierre Peters Perle du Mesnil LSNV followed next, paired with snow crab in a clear clam soup and sashimi. Pale, light-medium with less fizz but remarkably balanced with substantial wheat, yeast, toasty oak and a suggestion of depth. Not too dry on the finish. Excellent body. Expands further at the finish with biscuity, nutty flavours.
This was followed by Pierre Peters Cuvee de Reserve, Grand Cru, Blanc de Blancs NV (en magnum), paired with sea perch and sea urchin, apparently opened and aired for 24 hours under temperature control. The results are telling. Light-golden, biscuity with deep, crispy notes of toasty walnut, creme de la creme and a substantial oily-texture on the mid-palate. It gradually morphed into a seamless whole, the vibrant acidity ensuring a certain lightness of touch. Quite a complete champagne, I’d say, if it weren’t for the following wine that upstaged it.
The 2000 Pierre Peters Cuvee de Reserve “Les Chetillons” Grand Cru Blanc de Blancs represented the first time I’ve had champagne served in a white wine glass, and what an educational experience it turned out to be. Supposedly made from old vines over 45 years of age from three plots in the Grand Cru village of Mesnil-sur-Oger that the owners declared as “one of the finest pieces of land in Champagne”, and it shows. Very open. Fantastic bouquet full of secondary aromatics. Lives up to lofty expectations on the palate. Deeply complex and layered, producing a kaleidoscope of flavours and colors, more of yeast, apples, pineapples and peach, smoky, broad, smooth and expansive. Ripe yet elgant, the rich minerality enhancing the purity of the fruit. It reminded me of a Philipponnat. Absolutely beautiful. We paid the ultimate compliment by purchasing a case on-the-spot.
From Pierre Peters, we moved on to another champagne house also located within the village of Mesnil-sur-Oger since 1892: Champagne Guy Charlemagne. We were presented with the Brut Rose NV, made from 100% pinot noir, paired with river eel and mushroom rice. A lovely pinkish tint. Flavours of toasty oak and grapefruit producing that characteristic yeasty note, medium-bodied, the cutting acidity leading on to a dry finish. Developed some pungent barnyard as it sat in the glass, adding to a sense of depth. I’ve always enjoyed rose champagne and this example was without exception.
Next, a “mystery wine“. Powerful nose of petroleum character – reminding me instantly of turpentine as well as childhood days spent sniffing the fumes off the petrol cap of my father’s old Morris Minor. Highly addictive – the wine, I mean – with dense oily textures imbued with principal flavours of fig, nectar and apricot. Open and transparent without being heavy. It turned out to be the Guy Charlemagne Ratafia, made by fermenting the fresh must of pinot noir (from Champagne, of course) with a blend of liquor, 18% by alcohol and typically served as an aperitif in Champagne. Wow. I’m glad this came towards the end of dinner, but I’ll be happy to sip this quietly late at night on its own while watching a great movie.
And, finally, an 1989 Kesselstatt Scharzhofberger Beerenauslese to round off the evening’s proceedings. Deep ash cherry. Heavy, almost smoky, of cooked apples. Slightly resinous, dense, almost medicinal in quality, the low acidity and dry stern finish an instant cue that this wine has spent considerable time well into its maturity. Not unlike an aged sauternes just past its prime but, nevertheless, still enjoyable. I must thank Boon, and Wein & Vin, for such a generous and informative lineup, and I’ll be sure to drink more of these fabulous wines in time to come.
1995 Ch Calon Segur
The wifey and I shared a bottle of 1995 Ch Calon Segur at the restaurant Ember (at the 1929 Hotel) where the food is really quite excellent and reasonably priced (mains below SGD40), and the service prompt, friendly and highly efficient without any pretension, attracting a wine-savvy crowd who’d brought their own bottles, taking advantage of the relatively cheap corkage of only SGD20.
Popped and poured from bottle, the wine showed a deep garnet red with a violet rim, producing a lifted bouquet of blackberries, lovely ripe fruit, cassis and the classic minerality derived from the clay soils of St Estephe that defies accurate description (a trace of chalky firmness in the background), combining into a wine that probably would have been quite hedonistic in its youth. Very harmonious right from the start, soft, yet imbued with the right degree of intensity. It mellowed quite rapidly in the glass, its core opening up to reveal greater depth and transparency. Beautifully integrated, transforming further after 60 minutes, gaining weight and concentration, the fruit being more focused, the wine more complex, developing some velvety tannins as it glides into a savoury, persistent finish. Seemed more youthful and weightier than a bottle drank in Aug 2009 (see blog entry “Ward 48 dinner at Jade Palace”). At its peak now, and will probably still hold for many more years to come. Excellent.






